Marriage should be a choice
But if saying no was never on the table, does your yes mean yes?
Why this focus matters
- For many people, a shidduch with family guidance can lead to a lasting marriage.
- We want shidduchim to be free of pressure.
- You should be able to make a real choice over who you marry, when you marry, and whether you marry at all.
- Pressure can be as direct as a threat, or as subtle as unspoken expectations that can’t be meaningfully challenged.
- Under 18, any marriage is legally considered forced – with or without pressure.
Chaya’s story
What Forced Marriage can look like in a shidduch process:
My name is Chaya. I am the oldest of nine. I love looking after my siblings. But I actually can't wait to have my own house so I can do things my own way.
School was easy for me; I got mostly 9s in my GCSEs last summer, and I’m currently in Seminary. I had signed up to do two A-levels, but once I got here, only one, Maths, actually worked out.
Quite a few of my friends got engaged in their first year of Sem, and I’ve been looking forward to my turn.
*Names and details have been changed to protect the people involved.
Just before exams began, my parents told me that a really good boy had been suggested. I was nervous but excited; it was finally happening.
My parents had already met the boy's parents, and all the finances had been agreed. They seemed happy.
The night we met, my parents and his waited in one room, with cake and a l'chaim (liquor) ready to celebrate, while I sat across from the boy at the dining room table. He smiled at me when I walked in, which was a bit embarrassing as I had never spoken to a boy before.
He said I was the second girl he had met, and he tried to fill the silence with questions, but it was really awkward.
After twenty minutes, my father knocked on the door, and I was so relieved to see his face.
He asked me if I was saying yes. I said I didn't know. He said, "If it isn't a no, then it’s a yes".
My father sang out, "Mazal tov!" My mother hugged me, and my future mother-in-law gave me a diamond bracelet. At the tenoim (engagement party), both fathers signed the tenoim agreement. It was in Hebrew and was signed on the men's side of the mechitza. I'm not sure what was in it, although they did call me over when it was time to sign it.
I have just one photo of the two of us together, standing on either side of a big flower arrangement.
I keep that photo under my pillow, hoping every night we will build a bustling, happy home together, but… I don't know him at all.
A friend got married a few months ago and told me what her first night was like. I asked my mother if it was true, and she said it’s nothing to be scared of and that I will get used to it, and eventually enjoy it.
That's it – I'm getting married next year. We can't talk until then, and I don't know what I would say to him if we did.
What we’re doing about it
Nahamu’s ongoing work in this sector takes the form of
- Reviewing current and upcoming legislation
- Identifying areas that need better enforcement
- Engaging the community in conversation on this issue
- Bringing this issue to the fore, nationally and globally.
Because if saying no was never on the table, your yes doesn’t mean yes.
Jewish marriage needs a better conversation
Nahamu’s path to change
We understand you have questions; if you don’t see your answer here, Contact Us >
What is forced marriage?
You have the right to choose who you marry, when you marry or if you marry at all.
In the UK, forced marriage is against the law.
Forced marriage is when you face pressure to marry (for example, threats, physical violence or sexual violence) or emotional and psychological pressure (e.g. if you’re made to feel like you’re embarrassing your family or ruining prospects for other family members). It also includes causing someone who lacks the mental capacity to consent to marry, even where no pressure is used.
It is an offence to do anything intended to cause someone under 18 to marry, even if there is no physical or emotional pressure or abuse involved. This includes religious ceremonies that are not legally recognised marriages.
What is the difference between a forced marriage and an arranged marriage?
In an arranged marriage, the people getting married have a choice about who they marry, when they marry, and whether they marry at all. In a forced marriage, they don’t. Not every arranged marriage is forced, but every forced marriage is also arranged.
What is a shidduch?
A shidduch (pl. shidduchim) is a matchmaking arrangement within the Jewish community. It describes any arrangement where the couple getting married did not meet each other independently.
This exists on a spectrum that varies from online platforms where people upload their profiles and are matched either by an algorithm or human matchmakers and then left to get to know each other, all the way through to parents who make arrangements for their children in which the children have little or no say about who they marry, when they marry, or whether they marry at all.
There are lots of other situations between both of those extremes that would also be called a shidduch, for example a couple being introduced to each other by a friend, or a teacher, relative, rabbi or even a professional matchmaker suggesting to a parent that their son might be suitable for someone else’s daughter, and then facilitating an introduction between the two families. Sometimes adults will consult with matchmakers directly and ask to be introduced to someone.
The far end of the spectrum is where a shidduch crosses into forced marriage – which is against the law.
Does Nahamu believe that every shidduch is a forced marriage?
No. Shidduchim are part of our beautiful Jewish heritage. We want that to continue. But no one should be forced into a shidduch.
Is it only young people who can be forced into marriage?
It is an offence to do anything intended to cause someone under 18 to marry, even without pressure or abuse. This includes in the context of religious ceremonies that are not legally recognised marriages.
I am stuck in a forced marriage/at risk of a forced marriage. Can you help me?
Contact the Forced Marriage Unit (FMU) if you’re trying to stop a forced marriage or you need help leaving a marriage you’ve been forced into.
Forced Marriage Unit
Email: fmu@fcdo.gov.uk
Telephone: 020 7008 0151
From overseas: +44 (0)20 7008 0151
Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm
Out of hours: 020 7008 5000
My spouse and I both agree we were forced into our marriage. We feel traumatised, but we also feel connected. Can a marriage start forced but then become consensual?
It’s understandable to feel both of those things. Two adults may subsequently freely choose to remain together, although that does not undo the original coercion or any offence committed. A marriage can become genuinely consensual over time but what matters is whether you both have a real, free choice now, not just that you’ve grown attached. Individual support can help you work through that, and couples therapy too, if that’s what you both want going forward.
I have left my husband but he won’t give me a gett. Can a marriage become forced?
A marriage entered into freely can later become a relationship in which someone is trapped through abuse. Refusing to grant a gett can be a form of domestic abuse involving coercive and controlling behaviour. This is a legal offence distinct from the offence of forcing someone to enter a marriage. You can read more about how this works in the government’s guidance.