A choice you were never offered isn’t tradition
It’s control, dressed up as something older
Why this focus matters
- What if almost every small detail in your life was chosen for you? Right down to the colour of your socks, and whether you are allowed to drive or ride a bike.
- For many, this isn’t something that needs to be imagined. Even making small lifestyle changes risks serious social consequences.
- Sometimes this becomes so unbearable that people leave Judaism altogether, so that they can breathe, and make their own choices.
- We want people to have more say in how they live their lives day to day. Because “conform or leave” is not a real choice.
Leah’s story
My name is Leah. I always knew that when I would get married, I would shave my hair and cover my head with a silk tichel (scarf). That is what my mother did, and as far as I knew, that was required by Jewish law.
*Names and details have been changed to protect the people involved.
The morning after my wedding, my head was shaved. But instead of feeling special, I felt numb and cold.
My mother kissed me. “You are a link in the chain, Leah. Don’t break it.”
But my husband offered me something precious: to learn the texts with me, and we discovered that we were strong enough to work out what being Jewish meant to us.
I chose to let my hair grow again. I still cover it. But it is my decision to do so, and I choose the coverings that feel right for me.
Both of us have paid the price for this small freedom. My father stopped supporting us financially as soon as he saw me wearing a different hair covering. My husband works two jobs now, but we manage. I know my mother cries when she lights the candles on Friday night. She prays that we will go back to the way we were, before we found our own way.
Our daughter is turning three this year and we are applying to schools. So far, all the local ones have rejected our application.
What we’re doing about it
Nahamu’s ongoing work in this sector takes the form of
- Reviewing current and upcoming legislation on coercive and controlling behaviour.
- Campaigning to ensure everyone’s right to freedom of religion and belief (FoRB).
- Engaging the community in conversation on this issue, nationally and globally.
Because no one should have to give up their freedom to belong.
Research in progress
Make real choice part of the conversation?
Nahamu’s path to change
We understand you have questions; if you don’t see your answer here, Contact Us >
What is personal autonomy?
Personal autonomy means that within the law and subject to the rights of others, we retain the ability to make decisions about ourselves and our lives.
We all live with rules, responsibilities and obligations. Some come from the law. Some come from our families, workplaces, religions or communities. Some are commitments we freely choose to make. Personal autonomy does not require you to deny your religious tradition, or to stop taking religious teaching seriously. It does mean that other people cannot simply assume authority over your life. There is an important difference between believing that a religious rule applies to you, choosing to follow it, and another person controlling you in the name of that rule.
Being part of a family, religion or community does not mean giving up your right to make personal decisions.
What is honour-based abuse?
Abuse is physical (hitting or shoving someone), sexual (touching them inappropriately), emotional (shouting, manipulating or isolating someone) or financial (taking their money, or making them work for no pay) harm that is imposed on one person by another. It can also include neglect (leaving them in wet or dirty clothes, not providing food or access to medical care). Sexual abuse within a marriage is also against the law; no one is entitled to have sex with you, even if you are married to them. Abuse is against the law and should be reported to the relevant authorities, which will be different depending where you live.
‘Honour’-based abuse describes abuse that is perpetrated to respond to the way a victim has, or might, embarrass or dishonour the perpetrator, their family, community or even the victim themselves. Such abuse is perpetrated when the abuser perceives that the victim has not, is or may not comply with the accepted community norms.
Honour-based abuse can include causing another person to engage in abusive behaviour towards the victim and can be a single incident or pattern of behaviour.
If I want to belong to a community, should I not have to keep to community norms?
People may freely choose to live according to religious teachings, cultural traditions or community norms, but belonging to your community should not mean giving up your personal autonomy.
A person can choose to follow a rule because it is meaningful to them. That is different from being forced to follow it through threats, intimidation, abuse, or unacceptable consequences.
Before I got married, I agreed to shave my hair, but I don’t want to anymore. Do I not need to keep the commitment that I made?
An agreement made in the past does not mean you lose the right to make decisions about your own body in the present and future.
When does encouragement or advice become pressure?
Advice leaves you free to disagree. Pressure is when the consequences of saying no are used to make you do what the other person wants.
That can include repeated demands, threats, humiliation, intimidation, withdrawing access to your money or housing, threatening relationships with children, excluding someone from family or community life, or involving other people to persuade or punish them. Remember, if you can’t say ‘no’, your ‘yes’ does not mean yes.
My beliefs have changed and I want to leave my community, but I don’t know anyone in the outside world, and I am worried about losing custody of my children. Where can I get help?
I have made some lifestyle changes after which I lost my job. Where can I get help?
Dismissal or other unfavourable treatment because of your religion or belief, including a lack of religion or belief, may be unlawful discrimination. Changing your religion or belief, including changing to having no belief at all, should not affect your employment. If it does, you should seek advice from Acas or a qualified solicitor. Paperweight is a Jewish charity that may be able to connect you with solicitors working on a volunteer basis, and they can also advise on financial matters. Losing community support and losing your legal rights are not the same thing. You may have more options than you have been led to believe.
I made some lifestyle changes, and my children have lost their school places. Where can I get help?
This depends on what type of school your children attend. If your children attend a state school (local authority maintained, academy, or pupil referral unit), you can get a good understanding of your position from the Department for Education’s guide for parents. You could also contact your local council’s education team. Exclusion from an independent school is governed by its contract and policies, subject to applicable law, including equality law. You may need advice from an education solicitor.
However, the help you need may be more related to admissions arrangements at a school more suited to your family. Admission arrangements vary by school and will be available on their website or by request from their office. Admissions to mainstream maintained schools and academies in England must comply with the School Admissions Code. At these state schools, a child must not be suspended or permanently excluded because of their parents’ behaviour. For more bespoke signposting on admissions, you can contact us.
I made some lifestyle changes and lost my housing. Where can I get help?
Changing your religion or belief, including changing to having no belief at all, should not affect your housing. If it does, you should seek advice as soon as possible from Citizens Advice or Shelter. Your legal position will depend on the type of housing you have, who provides it, why you are being asked to leave, and what evidence you can provide.
Your local authority has duties towards people who are homeless or at risk of homelessness, and they employ specialist housing advisers who can help you understand your options. Losing community support and losing your legal rights are not the same thing. You may have more options than you have been led to believe.