For most children, school opens doors
For some, the doors are shut before they’re old enough to notice
Why this focus matters
- When a child leaves school without a solid background in English and maths, or a recognised qualification, their choices narrow year by year.
- They can still build a good life – many do – but only within a shrinking set of options. If that path stops working for them, they often don't have another to fall back on.
- Secular education should sit alongside religious education, so that growing up becomes a pathway full of meaningful choices.
Tuli’s story
My name is Tuli. I had a couple of hours of secular education a day until I turned 13. I never quite got the hang of reading fluently in English and but I am pretty good at maths.
I started Yeshiva after my bar mitzvah. I always enjoyed learning Torah but I don’t want to stay in learning long-term the way my father did. I’m not sure I want to go into business; I wouldn’t know where to start or what to do!
Some of my friends feel more confident than I do, but I don’t see how I can earn a dignified living without qualifications.
I am living with choices that were made for me when I was just three years old. I have heard about people who left and went to university. They lost everything – I really don’t want that.
I am 17 now, and I am next in my family to get married. I expect it to happen within a year. Then, I will have a family of my own.
*Names and details have been changed to protect the people involved.
What we’re doing about it
Nahamu’s ongoing work in this sector takes the form of
- Publishing research on the secular education gap – from unregistered yeshivas to registered schools offering limited secular content.
- Briefing government where inspection and enforcement fall short.
- Pushing to register every school, inspect it, and hold it to the same standard.
- Engaging the community on why secular education and Torah study aren’t in competition.
Our goal is for every Jewish child to leave school literate and numerate in English, alongside their religious studies.
Ensure every Jewish child leaves school with real choices
Nahamu’s path to change
We understand you have questions; if you don’t see your answer here, Contact Us >
What do we think is the minimum level of non-religious education that parents should give their children?
This means at least 3 hours of daily secular study from age five to eighteen, with children leaving school fluent in English and achieving good passes in at least 5 GCSEs – Maths, English language, double science, and a humanity.
Children with artistic or sporting talent should be given the opportunity to develop their abilities.
After the age of sixteen, all teens – including those attending yeshivas and seminaries – should have the choice of 3 A levels in subjects like Maths, History, Geography, Physics, Chemistry and Biology that keep the widest range of university and career options open, or vocational courses such as T-levels.
What happens when freedom of religion and UK law clashes? What’s your view on providing children with sex and relationship education (SRE)?
The freedom to hold religious beliefs is protected. In the UK, that freedom has legal limits, and can be restricted where necessary to protect, among other things, the rights and freedoms of others, to the extent necessary in a democratic society.
Sex and relationship education protects children and prevents future harm. It should be a requirement in every school, and can, and should, be delivered in an age-appropriate way that is sensitive to Jewish beliefs while meeting legal requirements.
Why does anyone need access to higher education? There are plenty of people who have jobs inside the community. Isn’t that enough?
Religious practice should never limit a person's real options in life. Children need access to good quality education, to equip them with the right skills to make meaningful choices about the life they lead as adults.
Adults should know enough about UK society, and have enough English fluency, to comply with the law and communicate with people outside their community – so university or employment outside the Charedi community stays genuinely open to them, if that's what they want.
Without education, employment chances are restricted to a very narrow range of jobs inside the community. Those with professional aspirations may struggle to gain the necessary qualifications, while those without access to capital investment may struggle to establish or expand a business.
Does Jewish law prevent Yeshivas from registering with the DfE?
No, nothing in Jewish law prevents registration with the DfE. Most Charedi children, including boys, already attend registered schools: the sisters of boys at unregistered yeshivas typically attend registered secondary schools, and the boys themselves attended registered primary schools (chedorim).
Most Orthodox Jews want a good secular education for their children, and the standard at Orthodox Jewish maintained schools is already high; several Charedi boys' and girls' secondary schools prepare students for GCSEs, and some for A levels too.
If Chassidic primary schools (chedorim) are registered, and girls’ Chassidic secondary schools are registered, and there are also registered Charedi boys’ secondary schools, why is there such resistance to registering the Yeshivas?
Girls and boys under 13 aren't fully obligated in daily Torah study under Jewish law, so their secular education is generally seen as acceptable. Many Chassidic girls' schools still avoid A levels, since university could delay marriage and childbearing. But Yeshivas could combine full Jewish and secular education, much as chedorim already do.
The resistance isn't really about Jewish law; it's about fear of losing time to it. Many Chassidic groups worry that registration would reduce Torah study, at a moment when rebuilding the generation of learning lost in the Holocaust is seen as a central mission. There are also concerns about meeting the wider independent school regulations.
Didn’t Holocaust survivors want to protect yeshiva education from state interference?
Some Holocaust survivors' names were attached as signatories to letters opposing regulation, although it isn't always clear these reflect their considered views and a handful of individuals can't speak for all survivors.
Others have said the opposite. Ita Simons MBE, in an interview with Stephen Brook for his book The Club: The Jews of Modern Britain, said she worries that Chassidic boys without secular education are "so poorly equipped to deal with making a living" unless they have family wealth or a business to fall back on.
In fact, most Holocaust survivors who settled in the UK wanted their children to have a secular education alongside their Jewish one. Hasmonean High School – a girls' and boys' multi-academy trust in North West London – was founded during the Second World War for Orthodox Jewish Kindertransport refugees who wanted exactly that: a full Jewish and secular education.
How do young men who attended these Yeshivas manage without education?
Some are reliant on welfare and low salaries; they were particularly impacted by welfare cuts. Many run their own small businesses. But there are allegations of widespread welfare fraud - not everyone will be able to make enough money to support growing families.
Some do go on to improve their English and obtain qualifications. But it's hard to make up for a missed education while also supporting a young family, and for many, that means living close to the breadline, doing what they can for a growing household without the qualifications that could lead to better-paid work. Without family wealth to fall back on, that gap tends to follow people for life.
Yeshiva graduates spend years honing their analytical skills through Talmud study and find it easy to catch up if they want to go to university later
This common but misleading claim belittles the struggles men experience after they were denied secular education. Catching up on years of missed secular education while also supporting a growing family is genuinely hard. Former Yeshiva students now at university have spoken publicly about this, and given evidence to ministers and MPs through All-Party Parliamentary Groups (APPGs).
It's easier for those who spoke English at home, or attended a cheder with a stronger secular curriculum, but for many, the gap is real and lasting.
Isn’t the disproportionate impact of the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act on Yeshivas evidence of antisemitic intent?
No, if anything, this argument gets it backwards. Every British child is entitled to a broad and balanced education, and most get one, at maintained or independent schools working towards GCSEs, A levels, or BTECs that open up a range of careers. Believing it doesn't matter that Chassidic boys miss out is a racism of low expectations, as you’re expecting less of children because of their faith and sex.
Is safeguarding really a reason to regulate Yeshivas?
Yes. After hearing evidence from safeguarding experts, community leaders – including the Union of Orthodox Hebrew Congregations (UOHC) – and civil servants, the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse recommended that the government change the law so that:
- To designate any setting where a child spends most of their school time as a registered school, whatever it currently calls itself, so it's covered by the same safeguarding rules as every other school.
- To give Ofsted the power to check child protection standards when it inspects settings suspected of operating unregistered.
If Charedi boys are being homeschooled, why is the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act needed?
Homeschooling has to be provided full-time. No one can attend a Yeshiva for around 50 hours a week, including Sundays, and also receive full-time homeschooling.
Some Chassidic boys get a couple of hours of private tuition in maths and English a week, but that's neither universal nor full-time. That falls short of the government’s guidance for homeschooling, which is why the Act also creates a homeschooling register, with stronger regulation to match.
Doesn’t the Human Rights Act guarantee that the State shall respect the parents’ rights to ensure that their child’s education conforms with their religious and philosophical convictions?
Even if a religious group could prove that providing their sons with a secular education went against their religious convictions, that right isn’t absolute. The right to respect for parents’ religious convictions in education does not prevent proportionate measures to protect children. In a House of Lords case on corporal punishment in religious schools – where parents argued discipline in keeping with Mishlei (Proverbs) 13:24 (‘Spare the rod, spoil the child’) was part of their faith, the court found that religious freedom has to be weighed against the harm caused to the child. (2005)
The harm caused by denying Charedi boys an appropriate secular education falls first on each individual, but it ripples out to Charedi communities, the wider Orthodox Jewish world, and society as a whole.